Spirit Cruises January 2023 Leaderboard

Behind the Spirit: Aaron Selya, Master Distiller of Philadelphia Distilling

by Drink Philly on Jul 25, 2018 in Culture

For our first installment of Behind the Spirit, we spoke to Aaron Selya, the head distiller at Philadelphia Distilling (home of Bluecoat American Dry Gin). Selya, who grew up in Hatfield, attended Indiana University of Pennsylvania, and currently lives in Fishtown, has worked for Philadelphia Distilling since 2014. We chatted about traditional London dry gin, his background in research, and Swiss absinthe.
Drink Philly (DP): Tell me about Philadelphia Distilling.
Aaron Selya (AS): Philadelphia Distilling was the first distillery in PA since Prohibition, and it started in 2005. A great story is that when they applied for their distillery license, PA wasn’t granting them at all, so they actually got a brewery license and crossed out “brewery!”
The tasting room opened in 2017, and having the tasting room and distillery next to each other has been really incredible, in that working this closely with amazing bartenders has made me think way more about cocktails. I think working in this space has also helped me think about our spirits in a different way — we have so many representatives, and we bring them in to show them the process and talk about the spirit all the time. Bringing cocktails into that process has made me think more about the spirit as not just a spirit, but a mixing component and its overall flavor structure — and most importantly, why Bluecoat Gin works so well.
DP: Where did you work before this, and how did you get into distilling?
AS: After college, I worked at Johns Hopkins’ medical school as a researcher in immunology, and Abby, my partner to this day, was also a researcher there in a different lab. Once she got her degree in library and information science, she got a job at University of Utah, so I moved with her and got a job at a brewery in Salt Lake City called Epic Brewing as the lead cellarman, after homebrewing and working at a homebrew shop and SLC elsewhere in Utah. My parents made wine a lot growing up, and I helped them with that throughout my childhood and teenage years, so I was really familiar with the idea of making your own alcohol. Abby and I wanted to move out of Utah, so we came back to the Philadelphia area and I started here. When I started, I was hired as a distiller, and became head distiller in an official capacity once we opened the new distillery and tasting room.
DP: Describe a typical workday for you.
AS: We’re doing 24 hour Bluecoat Gin production right now, so I’ll get here around 4 AM when we’re in that process. I check in with whomever took the overnight shift about what needs to be done, and then start thinking about bigger things — packaging for the day, packaging for the future, what products need to be dealt with — and really just manage the day to day operations of the distillery itself. I also deal with bigger picture issues like scheduling, storage and inventory. Overall, I manage a team of 10-12 people and I try not to work more than 9-10 hours.
DP: What’s trendy in spirits right now?
AS: I’d like to think gin is trending right now! I definitely have a pretty skewed view of that, because I interact with people who want to talk about gin more than other spirits. I think whiskey is still trending upwards, and I think we’re seeing small trends where people are looking for more savory flavors in their gin. Rums are also getting really popular, especially funkier rums.
DP: What’s a trend in spirits that you wish would die?
AS: This is a personal preference for me, but I don’t like gins that have a lot of late palate, warm, baking spice flavors, like cloves.
DP: Any predictions about where the industry might go next?
AS: I think local spirits are getting bigger and bigger. We saw this big emphasis in the beer world on locally produced beer, and I think the spirits world will focus on liquors that are made locally going forward.
DP: One unexpected fact about you?
AS: Originally, I wanted to work in viral genetics and medical research.
DP: What’s special about gin?
AS: Gin is interesting in the world of traditional spirits because it’s not a “base” spirit. It’s not directly resulting from the distillation of a specific sugar source, like whiskey. Gin is kind of like a second tier of spirit, where it’s essentially a flavored version of the distillation product. You’re adding flavors into what is essentially a finished product, and distilling it again, so it’s a variation of a base spirit, but the possibility of flavors is much broader because you’re not limited to the flavors that come up during the distillation of a specific source — you have a huge range of botanicals that you can use in gin.
DP: Philadelphia Distilling recently released their first “expression,” Elderflower. What was the creative process like for that gin? Can we expect more expressions in the future?
AS: Well, I’ve been working on developing my own amaro, so I had a variety of botanicals I was bringing into the tasting room. We’ve been playing with infusing Bluecoat Gin with things like elderflower and rose hips for a number of years. When we moved into this space, we wanted to create a distillery exclusive of Bluecoat Gin that would bring people into the distillery and tasting room itself, so we looked at the test infusions we’d been making. We tried elderflower, and it seemed to really have some legs, so we tested it in some cocktails with Canyon [Shayer, the bar manager at Philadelphia Distilling]. We definitely have more expressions in the works, but I’d like to play those close to the chest. We made 600 bottles at first, and we sold about 500 bottles the first week.
DP: What’s different about Bluecoat Gin?
AS: The amount of citrus in Bluecoat Gin is very different than a traditional London dry gin, in that we add way more, which means that the citrus softens the impact of the juniper so you don’t get the sharpness of that flavor. On your palate, when you experience the gin, the juniper is forced to almost compete with the citrus. We also use a less harsh juniper than others do.
DP: Do you have a favorite Philadelphia Distilling product?
AS: Vieux Carré Absinthe has a special place in my heart, because like a true Philadelphian, I’m a fan of the underdog. I’ve got some Swiss heritage, and as a kid, I went to Switzerland. Ours is made in a very Swiss tradition.
DP: What’s your favorite beer?
AS: Rauch beers or smoked beers — similar to absinthe, I like the underdog! Not a lot of people make rauch beers anymore. I also drink a lot of Victoria from Mexico, made by Modelo.
DP: What’s your favorite cocktail?
AS: A 50-50 martini, which I first tried at Urban Farmer. It really opened my mind to 50-50 martinis.
DP: What’s a cocktail faux pas you hate?
AS: Ice shards in my drink — it’s a result of overshaking, under-straining, and bad ice.
DP: What do you think the essentials are for a good home bar?
AS: Bluecoat Gin! But really, I think you need stuff for classic cocktails, like a good (but not too expensive) bourbon for mixing, some bitters, and good vermouth (that you keep in your fridge). I also think people should practice making fresh juice and fresh simple syrup.
DP: Where do you go for a drink when you’re not working?
AS: I have a lot of respect for tons of bartenders throughout Philly, but since I live in the neighborhood, some spots I stop into a lot are Lloyd and Kensington Quarters.
DP: Are there any distillers in Philadelphia you’re a fan of?
AS: Dean Browne at Rowhouse Spirits and Walter Palmer at Palmer Distilling Company are two other gin-makers in Philadelphia, and they’re both great — plus, their gins are totally different from Bluecoat Gin.
DP: What advice would you give to someone who wants to become a distiller?
AS: Having some chemistry background isn’t necessary, but it’s definitely helpful. There’s a lot about the distillation process where it helps to know some of the science behind it. Otherwise, just like brewing or a lot of other beverage production, there’s a lot of cleaning — so if you don’t like cleaning, this may not be the job for you. I also think distillers need pretty broad palates, so familiarize yourself with different types of spirits as much as you can. I think that when you say someone has a “good” palate, it just means someone is good at putting what they’re tasting into words, so most people can build up those neural pathways and have a “good” palate.
DP: If you could have a drink with any famous person, living or dead, who would it be, what would you drink, and why?
AS: Not to be too “on brand,” but probably one of the founding fathers. Maybe Franklin or Jefferson. I’d love to pick their brains about starting a new country and how they imagined it would develop. And, of course, we would have to talk about spirits and alcohol, what flavors they like and what they don’t like. I’d like to think they’d be into Bluecoat Gin.
Photos via Drink Philly

Tags: Behind the Bar, Behind the Spirit
Recent Articles


How are we doing? Tell us what you like or don't like and how we can improve. We would love to hear your thoughts!

Best Bars for Outdoor Drinking in Philadelphia, 2024

Best Bars for Outdoor Drinking in Philadelphia, 2024

We've got your definitive list of where to drink outside in Philadelphia...read more ›

by Drink Philly Apr 9, 2024
Philadelphia Distilling Launching Secret Pop-Up Cocktail Garden for Earth Day, April 11-21

Philadelphia Distilling Launching Secret Pop-Up Cocktail Garden for Earth Day, April 11-21

Philadelphia Distilling is transforming their fourth floor space into a secret garden to celebrate Earth Day, ...read more ›

by Drink Philly Apr 9, 2024
The Drink Nation Presents: The Home Bar Project

The Drink Nation Presents: The Home Bar Project

Have you ever dreamed of having an amazing home bar, filled with bottles you actually use and the tools you need to execute a fine crafted cocktail? E...read more ›

by The Drink Nation Nov 14, 2014
Drink Nation Store Rectangle
Dizengoff: Inside Look at the New Reimagined Restaurant, Bar, & Cocktails

Dizengoff: Inside Look at the New Reimagined Restaurant, Bar, & Cocktails

Last year, Dizengoff and Abe Fisher decided to join forces and embark on an exciting new chapter. After closin...read more ›

by Drink Philly Mar 5, 2024
Behind the Bar: Tom Foy of Butcher Bar

Behind the Bar: Tom Foy of Butcher Bar

In this installment of Behind the Bar, we sit down with bartender Tom Foy of Butcher Bar...read more ›

by Drink Philly Feb 19, 2024
48 Record Bar: An Inside Look at an Audiophile's Listening Room & Cocktail Bar

48 Record Bar: An Inside Look at an Audiophile's Listening Room & Cocktail Bar

48 Record Bar is the newest addition to the growing Listening Room trend in Philadelphia...read more ›

by Drink Philly Feb 19, 2024
The Best Cocktail Bars in Philadelphia

The Best Cocktail Bars in Philadelphia

In a city with new bar openings every week, it can be hard to keep up with the everchanging Philly cocktail landscape. Don't worry, we've got you cove...read more ›

by Drink Philly Dec 14, 2023
Best Bars for Outdoor Drinking in Philadelphia, 2023

Best Bars for Outdoor Drinking in Philadelphia, 2023

We've got your definitive list of where to drink outside in Philadelphia...read more ›

by Drink Philly May 27, 2023
Pamper Yourself at These Spas with Bars in Philadelphia

Pamper Yourself at These Spas with Bars in Philadelphia

Whether you're going solo or heading out with friends, we've got just the place for your to relax and enjoy a good drink...read more ›

by Jessie Donofrio Apr 5, 2023
The Best Mocktails, Zero Proof, & Non-Alcoholic Drinks in Philadelphia

The Best Mocktails, Zero Proof, & Non-Alcoholic Drinks in Philadelphia

Not drinking alcohol tonight? These bars and restaurants have you covered with inventive, thoughtful, and down...read more ›

by Michelle Cassidy Jan 11, 2023
Spirit Cruises January 2023 Desktop Bottom Rectangle 2
View all Articles

Sign up to get weekly drinking news, bar reviews, events and more sent directly to your inbox!